How to Set an Asking Price Buyers Can Compare

Last updated September 8, 2026

Published by Gia Freer, Broker of Record, PBP Real Estate, LLC · Florida broker license BK689801

An asking price needs support from similar sold properties and current competition, not a promised discount curve. If you are deciding whether to list high and adjust later, start with evidence for your property rather than a market-wide rule.

Correction — September 8, 2026

We are correcting the scope and interpretation of our earlier study. Our earlier study was described as covering only Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, Martin and St. Lucie counties, but the calculation did not restrict the whole-study sample to those counties. Its total does not match its named county subtotals. We also described original and final price endpoints as complete price histories, recorded market-time fields as verified time to contract, and differences between sold-listing groups as evidence of buyer behavior or negotiating leverage. Those claims went beyond the analysis.

We have retained the original figures below, clearly marked not cleared for citation. We have not found the exact original listing-level file in the sources checked, so we have not replaced the figures with a newer dataset or presented corrected five-county medians. This does not establish that every original ratio is wrong. The related social materials remain held from new distribution.

This date marks the correction, not a fresh analysis of the historical sales. See the public corrections log.

Which price should a seller compare?

Original asking price, final asking price and closing price answer different questions. An asking price is a seller's advertised position; a closing price records the sale. Neither, on its own, explains why a buyer made an offer.

Original asking price: the first asking price recorded for that listing. It provides a starting point for that listing's price comparison, not a complete account of earlier listings.
Final asking price: the last recorded asking price in the sold-listing record. Comparing it with the original tells you the difference between those endpoints, not every intervening change.
Closing price: the recorded sale price. Always ask which asking price a reported percentage uses. A ratio against the final ask is not interchangeable with one against the original ask.

What evidence should support your asking price?

Start with properties that are genuinely comparable to yours, then examine what is competing with you now. Keep houses separate from condominiums and review townhouses and villas as their own property type. A broad area average cannot account for your home's condition, view or updates.

Review similar sold properties. Ask why each property belongs in the comparison: location, property type, size, condition and sale date. Ask which differences need a human adjustment.
Check current competition. Review the asking prices and condition of properties a buyer could compare with yours. For an association property, examine the applicable fees, documents and restrictions rather than assuming all communities are alike.
Agree on a review plan. Decide with your agent how showing feedback, competing listings and your timeline will inform the next pricing conversation. No historical percentage guarantees your outcome.

Historical figures — not cleared for citation

The original numbers remain available for transparency, not as verified pricing evidence. Labels below have been corrected to describe the fields actually used. The former charts are shown as data tables so their original values remain readable alongside the hold notices.

Open the September 7 historical figures and correction details — not cleared for citation

All figures in this section are historical and not cleared for citation. They have not been recomputed. The original study covered sales dated September 1, 2025 through August 31, 2026, using a September 7, 2026 retrieval. The geography issue affects the whole-study groups and cannot be repaired by changing their headline count alone.

How to read the corrected field labels

Recorded market days: the source's CumulativeDaysOnMarket field, with DaysOnMarket used only when the cumulative field was absent. Zero cumulative days stayed zero. The script did not calculate the interval between listing and contract dates or independently reconstruct relistings.
Original condo/townhouse group: the historical grouping rule combined condominiums, townhouses and villas, and also allowed stock cooperatives through its property-subtype rule. A condominium legal description overrode the listed subtype; otherwise subtype fallback applied. The historical grouping is retained, not silently split or renamed as condominium-only data. Its exact subtype counts have not been independently revalidated.
Percentages: closing/original and closing/final figures are medians of individual listing-level ratios. Shares are proportions of the labeled group, not medians. Do not multiply group medians to infer another ratio.
Limits: these are different groups of sold listings, not a controlled comparison of pricing strategies. Unsold listings are absent. Buyer perceptions, offer counts and negotiating leverage were not measured; condition, location and season were not controlled.

Why the original sample is on hold

Historical — not cleared for citation. The original aggregate is preserved. Its whole-study counts include records with missing, unrecognized or out-of-scope county values; the original listing-level file is needed to determine that breakdown. Subtracting the count difference would not produce corrected medians.

Historical — not cleared for citation. Reconciliation of the retained original aggregate, checked September 8, 2026; these are counts, not replacement price statistics.
Original group	Whole-study count	Five named counties	County not assigned to a named group
Houses	41,830	39,221	2,609
Original condo/townhouse group	34,873	34,410	463
Total observations (counts only)	76,703	73,631	3,072

Original edition: BeachesMLS listings permitted for internet display, via PBP Real Estate's brokerage feed; sales dated September 2025 through August 2026, retrieved September 7, 2026. Geography unresolved for the whole-study groups. This data is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. Based on information (c) 2026 BeachesMLS, Inc.

Original chart values: closing price versus original ask

Historical — not cleared for citation. These are the original chart's median listing-level closing/original-price ratios, now shown as a table. The bands use recorded market days, not a verified contract-date calculation. They do not measure how waiting changes the price of the same property.

Historical — not cleared for citation. Median listing-level closing price as a percentage of original asking price, by recorded market-time band.
Recorded market-time band (days)	Houses	Original condo/townhouse group
0-14 days	98.9%	97.6%
15-30	96.6%	95.8%
31-60	94.8%	93.9%
61-120	92.4%	91.5%
121+	89.5%	86.9%

Historical — not cleared for citation. These are the original chart's proportions, not medians. Later bands also contain at-or-above-original outcomes; the figures do not establish a first-month-only rule.

Historical — not cleared for citation. Share of sold listings closing at or above their original asking price, by recorded market-time band.
Recorded market-time band (days)	Houses	Original condo/townhouse group
0-14 days	44.1%	32.2%
15-30	21.8%	16.5%
31-60	11.7%	8.5%
61-120	6.6%	4.2%
121+	4.3%	2.4%

Original table: original and final asking-price groups

Historical — not cleared for citation. Final at or above original does not mean the listing was never reduced. Final below original describes the two recorded endpoints; it does not establish when or how many times the price changed. Counts and shares are labeled separately from medians.

Historical — not cleared for citation. Original price-endpoint groups; values preserved, definitions corrected.
Measure	Houses	Original condo/townhouse group
Sold listings in the study window	41,830	34,873
Final list price at or above original: share (count)	55.5% (23,230)	50.7% (17,677)
Median recorded market days: final at or above original	19	30
Median recorded market days: final below original	98	124
Median closing/original price (%): final at or above original	97.6%	96.0%
Median closing/original price (%): final below original	90.7%	87.5%
Median closing/final list price (%): final at or above original	97.5%	96.0%
Median closing/final list price (%): final below original	96.8%	95.5%
Share closing at or above original ask: final at or above original	32.4%	19.8%
Share closing at or above original ask: final below original	0.9%	0.4%

Original table: size of the endpoint difference

Historical — not cleared for citation. The original band values are unchanged. Closing/original price and final/original price share the original-price denominator. Their association does not show that reducing the asking price caused a worse result. Shares use all closings in that original property group as the denominator.

Historical — not cleared for citation. Difference between original and final recorded asking prices, not a complete reduction history.
Original-to-final price difference	Share of all group closings	Median recorded market days	Median closing/original price (%)	Median closing/final list price (%)
Houses (41,830 closings)
Final below original by under 3%	10.6%	70	95.6%	97.5%
Final below original by 3% to 6%	13.3%	85	92.7%	96.9%
Final below original by 6% to 10%	10.6%	111	88.9%	96.5%
Final below original by 10% or more	9.9%	146	81.6%	95.7%
Original condo/townhouse group (34,873 closings)
Final below original by under 3%	8.4%	85	94.7%	96.5%
Final below original by 3% to 6%	12.1%	99	91.5%	95.8%
Final below original by 6% to 10%	11.4%	124	87.8%	95.3%
Final below original by 10% or more	17.4%	173	78.9%	94.7%

Original table: the five named county groups

Historical — not cleared for citation. These county-specific figures are also held; retaining them does not independently validate the underlying records. Their counts exclude the records that were not assigned to a named county group.

Historical — not cleared for citation. Original named-county rows. Paired cells: final at or above original / final below original.
County	Sold listings	Share with final below original	Median recorded market days	Median closing/original price (%)
Houses
Miami-Dade	10,794	41.8%	22 / 100	97.4% / 90.4%
Broward	11,364	43.8%	18 / 96	97.9% / 91.1%
Palm Beach	11,352	43.0%	15 / 97	97.2% / 89.7%
Martin	1,410	48.4%	17 / 102	96.8% / 89.6%
St. Lucie	4,301	50.9%	18 / 93	98.5% / 92.2%
Original condo/townhouse group
Miami-Dade	11,603	45.3%	34 / 133	96.1% / 88.4%
Broward	10,999	51.4%	31 / 120	96.0% / 87.3%
Palm Beach	10,112	50.1%	24 / 119	96.1% / 86.8%
Martin	792	56.9%	26 / 115	96.0% / 87.6%
St. Lucie	904	59.2%	34 / 122	96.4% / 89.6%

Original selection rules, not a newly validated sample

The script excluded flagged short sales, REO, auctions and other distressed categories, along with unclassified property types or missing required fields. It excluded original, final or closing prices below $50,000; recorded market days outside 0 to 720; and closing/original ratios outside 0.4 to 1.6. Those filters are not proof that every excluded value was an error. The original raw archive contained 85,947 records; the program retained 76,703 for its selected window. These are preserved historical counts, not a new study.

Historical — not cleared for citation. A replacement five-county analysis would require its own pinned source, definitions and verification. Until then, use the explanations above to ask better questions, not the held figures to predict a sale.

Pricing questions and answers

Does a longer listing time prove a home will sell for less?

No. Recorded market time alone does not prove what a particular home will sell for. Comparisons between different sold properties cannot isolate the effect of waiting, condition, location or the initial asking price. Ask for similar sold properties and current competition before applying a market-wide pattern to your home.

Does reducing an asking price guarantee a better or worse result?

No. A comparison of original, final and closing prices does not show what would have happened without a reduction. It also leaves out listings that did not sell. Review the asking price alongside competing properties, condition, showing feedback and your timeline with your agent; do not treat a price change as a guaranteed outcome.

How does PBP Real Estate prepare a pricing opinion?

Gia Freer, Broker of Record, prepares your opinion of value by hand, using nearby sold properties of the same property type and reviewing condition, view, updates and current competition. PBP Real Estate does not publish an instant online estimate. You receive the opinion within one business day, with the sales it is based on attached.

Pricing a home correctly is a skill

What would a website never know about your home? Tell us about the view, condition, updates and details a data table cannot explain. Gia Freer, Broker of Record, prepares your opinion of value by hand, with the sales it is based on attached, within one business day.

Use the pricing form below to Get my home value. It is a human-prepared opinion, not an instant online estimate. Any current figures in that form are a separately dated snapshot, not a refreshed edition of the historical study above.

Source of the retained historical figures: BeachesMLS listings permitted for internet display, via PBP Real Estate's brokerage feed. This data is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. Based on information (c) 2026 BeachesMLS, Inc.

For sellers

Pricing a home is a skill. Start with the current competition and recent closed sales.

42.5% of active single-family houses listings in South Florida (five counties) have a recorded asking price below their original list price.

The data comes from the segment and recorded fields available in PBP Real Estate's BeachesMLS feed, as of the date shown. Gia Freer, Broker of Record, turns comparable sales and current competition into one written pricing opinion for your home, with the reasoning, before it goes live.

No website estimate, no automated number: a comparative market analysis done by hand, within one business day.

42.5%Recorded below original

57.5%Not recorded as below originalMay include unchanged prices, increases and missing-price records; not a never-cut count.

13,534 single-family houses for sale in South Florida (five counties). Source: BeachesMLS, as of September 8, 2026. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Seller Blink Rate™ is the share of active listings with a recorded asking price below the original list price. The denominator is all active listings in the segment. The complement may include unchanged prices, increases and missing-price records; it does not establish a price history.

Request a pricing opinion for your property

Your nameEmail

Phone (optional)Property address, city

Property typeThinking of selling

City and community, and anything about the home we should know

Reviewed by Gia Freer, Broker of Record (Lic. BK689801). Reply within one business day. No automated estimate is published on this site.